This makes it possible for the compiler to validate that a match block
matched all PostgreSQL versions we support.
## Problem
We did not have a complete picture about which places we had to test
against PG versions, and what format these versions were: The full PG
version ID format (Major/minor/bugfix `MMmmbb`) as transfered in
protocol messages, or only the Major release version (`MM`). This meant
type confusion was rampant.
With this change, it becomes easier to develop new version-dependent
features, by making type and niche confusion impossible.
## Summary of changes
Every use of `pg_version` is now typed as either `PgVersionId` (u32,
valued in decimal `MMmmbb`) or PgMajorVersion (an enum, with a value for
every major version we support, serialized and stored like a u32 with
the value of that major version)
---------
Co-authored-by: Arpad Müller <arpad-m@users.noreply.github.com>
## Problem
1. Safekeeper selection on the pageserver side isn't very dynamic. Once
you connect to one safekeeper, you'll use that one for as long as the
safekeeper keeps the connection alive. In principle, we could be more
eager, since the wal receiver connection can be cancelled but we don't
do that. We wait until the "session" is done and then we pick a new SK.
2. Picking a new SK is quite conservative. We will switch if:
a. We haven't received anything from the SK within the last 10 seconds
(wal_connect_timeout) or
b. The candidate SK is 1GiB ahead or
c. The candidate SK is in the same AZ as the PS or d. There's a
candidate that is ahead and we've not had any WAL within the last 10
seconds (lagging_wal_timeout)
Hence, we can end up with pageservers that are requesting WAL which
their safekeeper hasn't seen yet.
## Summary of changes
Downgrade warning log to info.
Updates storage components to edition 2024. We like to stay on the
latest edition if possible. There is no functional changes, however some
code changes had to be done to accommodate the edition's breaking
changes.
The PR has two commits:
* the first commit updates storage crates to edition 2024 and appeases
`cargo clippy` by changing code. i have accidentially ran the formatter
on some files that had other edits.
* the second commit performs a `cargo fmt`
I would recommend a closer review of the first commit and a less close
review of the second one (as it just runs `cargo fmt`).
part of https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/10918
## Problem
The interpreted WAL reader tracks the start of the current logical
batch.
This needs to be invalidated when the reader is reset.
This bug caused a couple of WAL gap alerts in staging.
## Summary of changes
* Refactor to make it possible to write a reproducer
* Add repro unit test
* Fix by resetting the start with the reader
Related https://github.com/neondatabase/cloud/issues/23935
## Problem
Safekeepers currently decode and interpret WAL for each shard
separately.
This is wasteful in terms of CPU memory usage - we've seen this in
profiles.
## Summary of changes
Fan-out interpreted WAL to multiple shards.
The basic is that wal decoding and interpretation happens in a separate
tokio task and senders
attach to it. Senders only receive batches concerning their shard and
only past the Lsn they've last seen.
Fan-out is gated behind the `wal_reader_fanout` safekeeper flag
(disabled by default for now).
When fan-out is enabled, it might be desirable to control the absolute
delta between the
current position and a new shard's desired position (i.e. how far behind
or ahead a shard may be).
`max_delta_for_fanout` is a new optional safekeeper flag which dictates
whether to create a new
WAL reader or attach to the existing one. By default, this behaviour is
disabled. Let's consider enabling
it if we spot the need for it in the field.
## Testing
Tests passed [here](https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/pull/10301)
with wal reader fanout enabled
as of
34f6a71718.
Related: https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/9337
Epic: https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/9329
## Problem
We want to extract safekeeper http client to separate crate for use in
storage controller and neon_local. However, many types used in the API
are internal to safekeeper.
## Summary of changes
Move them to safekeeper_api crate. No functional changes.
ref https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/9011
Hello! I was interested in potentially making some contributions to Neon
and looking through the issue backlog I found
[8200](https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/8200) which seemed
like a good first issue to attempt to tackle. I see it was assigned a
while ago so apologies if I'm stepping on any toes with this PR. I also
apologize for the size of this PR. I'm not sure if there is a simple way
to reduce it given the footprint of the components being changed.
## Problem
This PR is attempting to address part of the problem outlined in issue
[8200](https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/8200). Namely to
remove global static usage of timeline state in favour of
`Arc<GlobalTimelines>` and to replace wasteful clones of
`SafeKeeperConf` with `Arc<SafeKeeperConf>`. I did not opt to tackle
`RemoteStorage` in this PR to minimize the amount of changes as this PR
is already quite large. I also did not opt to introduce an
`SafekeeperApp` wrapper struct to similarly minimize changes but I can
tackle either or both of these omissions in this PR if folks would like.
## Summary of changes
- Remove static usage of `GlobalTimelines` in favour of
`Arc<GlobalTimelines>`
- Wrap `SafeKeeperConf` in `Arc` to avoid wasteful clones of the
underlying struct
## Some additional thoughts
- We seem to currently store `SafeKeeperConf` in `GlobalTimelines` and
then expose it through a public`get_global_config` function which
requires locking. This seems needlessly wasteful and based on observed
usage we could remove this public accessor and force consumers to
acquire `SafeKeeperConf` through the new Arc reference.
## Problem
https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/pull/9746 lifted decoding and
interpretation of WAL to the safekeeper.
This reduced the ingested amount on the pageservers by around 10x for a
tenant with 8 shards, but doubled
the ingested amount for single sharded tenants.
Also, https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/pull/9746 uses bincode which
doesn't support schema evolution.
Technically the schema can be evolved, but it's very cumbersome.
## Summary of changes
This patch set addresses both problems by adding protobuf support for
the interpreted wal records and adding compression support. Compressed
protobuf reduced the ingested amount by 100x on the 32 shards
`test_sharded_ingest` case (compared to non-interpreted proto). For the
1 shard case the reduction is 5x.
Sister change to `rust-postgres` is
[here](https://github.com/neondatabase/rust-postgres/pull/33).
## Links
Related: https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/9336
Epic: https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/9329
## Problem
For any given tenant shard, pageservers receive all of the tenant's WAL
from the safekeeper.
This soft-blocks us from using larger shard counts due to bandwidth
concerns and CPU overhead of filtering
out the records.
## Summary of changes
This PR lifts the decoding and interpretation of WAL from the pageserver
into the safekeeper.
A customised PG replication protocol is used where instead of sending
raw WAL, the safekeeper sends
filtered, interpreted records. The receiver drives the protocol
selection, so, on the pageserver side, usage
of the new protocol is gated by a new pageserver config:
`wal_receiver_protocol`.
More granularly the changes are:
1. Optionally inject the protocol and shard identity into the arguments
used for starting replication
2. On the safekeeper side, implement a new wal sending primitive which
decodes and interprets records
before sending them over
3. On the pageserver side, implement the ingestion of this new
replication message type. It's very similar
to what we already have for raw wal (minus decoding and interpreting).
## Notes
* This PR currently uses my [branch of
rust-postgres](https://github.com/neondatabase/rust-postgres/tree/vlad/interpreted-wal-record-replication-support)
which includes the deserialization logic for the new replication message
type. PR for that is open
[here](https://github.com/neondatabase/rust-postgres/pull/32).
* This PR contains changes for both pageservers and safekeepers. It's
safe to merge because the new protocol is disabled by default on the
pageserver side. We can gradually start enabling it in subsequent
releases.
* CI tests are running on https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/pull/9747
## Links
Related: https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/9336
Epic: https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/9329
## Problem
Two recently observed log errors indicate safekeeper tasks for a
timeline running after that timeline's deletion has started.
- https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/8972
- https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/8974
These code paths do not have a mechanism that coordinates task shutdown
with the overall shutdown of the timeline.
## Summary of changes
- Add a `Gate` to `Timeline`
- Take the gate as part of resident timeline guard: any code that holds
a guard over a timeline staying resident should also hold a guard over
the timeline's total lifetime.
- Take the gate from the wal removal task
- Respect Timeline::cancel in WAL send/recv code, so that we do not
block shutdown indefinitely.
- Add a test that deletes timelines with open pageserver+compute
connections, to check these get torn down as expected.
There is some risk to introducing gates: if there is code holding a gate
which does not properly respect a cancellation token, it can cause
shutdown hangs. The risk of this for safekeepers is lower in practice
than it is for other services, because in a healthy timeline deletion,
the compute is shutdown first, then the timeline is deleted on the
pageserver, and finally it is deleted on the safekeepers -- that makes
it much less likely that some protocol handler will still be running.
Closes: #8972Closes: #8974
## Problem
While experimenting with `MAX_SEND_SIZE` for benchmarking, I saw stack
overflows when increasing it to 1 MB. Turns out a few buffers of this
size are stack-allocated rather than heap-allocated. Even at the default
128 KB size, that's a bit large to allocate on the stack.
## Summary of changes
Heap-allocate buffers of size `MAX_SEND_SIZE`.
Fixes https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/6337
Add safekeeper support to switch between `Present` and
`Offloaded(flush_lsn)` states. The offloading is disabled by default,
but can be controlled using new cmdline arguments:
```
--enable-offload
Enable automatic switching to offloaded state
--delete-offloaded-wal
Delete local WAL files after offloading. When disabled, they will be left on disk
--control-file-save-interval <CONTROL_FILE_SAVE_INTERVAL>
Pending updates to control file will be automatically saved after this interval [default: 300s]
```
Manager watches state updates and detects when there are no actvity on
the timeline and actual partial backup upload in remote storage. When
all conditions are met, the state can be switched to offloaded.
In `timeline.rs` there is `StateSK` enum to support switching between
states. When offloaded, code can access only control file structure and
cannot use `SafeKeeper` to accept new WAL.
`FullAccessTimeline` is now renamed to `WalResidentTimeline`. This
struct contains guard to notify manager about active tasks requiring
on-disk WAL access. All guards are issued by the manager, all requests
are sent via channel using `ManagerCtl`. When manager receives request
to issue a guard, it unevicts timeline if it's currently evicted.
Fixed a bug in partial WAL backup, it used `term` instead of
`last_log_term` previously.
After this commit is merged, next step is to roll this change out, as in
issue #6338.
This is a preparation for
https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/6337.
The idea is to add FullAccessTimeline, which will act as a guard for
tasks requiring access to WAL files. Eviction will be blocked on these
tasks and WAL won't be deleted from disk until there is at least one
active FullAccessTimeline.
To get FullAccessTimeline, tasks call `tli.full_access_guard().await?`.
After eviction is implemented, this function will be responsible for
downloading missing WAL file and waiting until the download finishes.
This commit also contains other small refactorings:
- Separate `get_tenant_dir` and `get_timeline_dir` functions for
building a local path. This is useful for looking at usages and finding
tasks requiring access to local filesystem.
- `timeline_manager` is now responsible for spawning all background
tasks
- WAL removal task is now spawned instantly after horizon is updated
To avoid pageserver gc'ing data needed by standby, propagate standby apply LSN
through standby -> safekeeper -> broker -> pageserver flow and hold off GC for
it. Iteration of GC resets the value to remove the horizon when standby goes
away -- pushes are assumed to happen at least once between gc iterations. As a
safety guard max allowed lag compared to normal GC horizon is hardcoded as 10GB.
Add test for the feature.
Co-authored-by: Konstantin Knizhnik <knizhnik@neon.tech>
## Problem
There's allegedly a bug where if we connect a subscriber before WAL is
downloaded from the safekeeper, it creates an error.
## Summary of changes
Adds support for pausing safekeepers from sending WAL to computes, and
then creates a compute and attaches a subscriber while it's in this
paused state. Fails to reproduce the issue, but probably a good test to
have
---------
Co-authored-by: Arseny Sher <sher-ars@yandex.ru>
Previously we aggregated ps_feedback on each safekeeper and sent it to
walproposer with every AppendResponse. This PR changes it to send
ps_feedback to walproposer right after receiving it from pageserver,
without aggregating it in memory. Also contains some preparations for
implementing backpressure support for sharding.
Add `--walsenders-keep-horizon` argument to safekeeper cmdline. It will
prevent deleting WAL segments from disk if they are needed by the active
START_REPLICATION connection.
This is useful for sharding. Without this option, if one of the shard
falls behind, it starts to read WAL from S3, which is much slower than
disk. This can result in huge shard lagging.
In the most straightforward way; safekeeper performs it in DELETE endpoint
implementation, with no coordination between sks.
delete_force endpoint in the code is renamed to delete as there is only one way
to delete.
safekeeper.rs is mostly about consensus, but state is wider. Also form
SafekeeperState which encapsulates persistent part + in memory layer with API
for atomic updates.
Moves remote_consistent_lsn back to SafekeeperMemState, fixes its absense from
memory dump.
Also renames SafekeeperState to TimelinePersistentState, as TimelineMemState and
TimelinePersistent state are created.
To exercise MAX_SEND_SIZE sending from safekeeper; we've had a bug with WAL
records torn across several XLogData messages. Add failpoint to safekeeper to
slow down sending. Also check for corrupted WAL complains in standby log.
Make the test a bit simpler in passing, e.g. we don't need explicit commits as
autocommit is enabled by default.
https://neondb.slack.com/archives/C05L7D1JAUS/p1703774799114719https://github.com/neondatabase/cloud/issues/9057
Improve the serde impl for several types (`Lsn`, `TenantId`,
`TimelineId`) by making them sensitive to
`Serializer::is_human_readadable` (true for json, false for bincode).
Fixes#3511 by:
- Implement the custom serde for `Lsn`
- Implement the custom serde for `Id`
- Add the helper module `serde_as_u64` in `libs/utils/src/lsn.rs`
- Remove the unnecessary attr `#[serde_as(as = "DisplayFromStr")]` in
all possible structs
Additionally some safekeeper types gained serde tests.
---------
Co-authored-by: Joonas Koivunen <joonas@neon.tech>
Implements fetching of WAL by safekeeper from another safekeeper by imitating
behaviour of last elected leader. This allows to avoid WAL accumulation on
compute and facilitates faster compute startup as it doesn't need to download
any WAL. Actually removing WAL download in walproposer is a matter of another
patch though.
There is a per timeline task which always runs, checking regularly if it should
start recovery frome someone, meaning there is something to fetch and there is
no streaming compute. It then proceeds with fetching, finishing when there is
nothing more to receive.
Implements https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/pull/4875
Instead of fixed during the start of replication. To this end, create
term_flush_lsn watch channel similar to commit_lsn one. This allows to continue
recovery streaming if new data appears.
It allows term leader to ensure he pulls data from the correct term. Absense of
it wasn't very problematic due to CRC checks, but let's be strict.
walproposer still doesn't use it as we're going to remove recovery completely
from it.
## Problem
The pageserver<->safekeeper protocol uses error messages to indicate end
of stream. pageserver already logs these at INFO level, but the inner
error message includes the word "ERROR", which interferes with log
searching.
Example:
```
walreceiver connection handling ended: db error: ERROR: ending streaming to Some("pageserver") at 0/4031CA8
```
The inner DbError has a severity of ERROR so DbError's Display
implementation includes that ERROR, even though we are actually
logging the error at INFO level.
## Summary of changes
Introduce an explicit WalReceiverError type, and in its From<>
for postgres errors, apply the logic from ExpectedError, for
expected errors, and a new condition for successes.
The new output looks like:
```
walreceiver connection handling ended: Successful completion: ending streaming to Some("pageserver") at 0/154E9C0, receiver is caughtup and there is no computes
```
General Rust Write trait semantics (as well as its async brother) is that write
definitely happens only after Write::flush(). This wasn't needed in sync where
rust write calls the syscall directly, but is required in async.
Also fix setting initial end_pos in walsender, sometimes it was from the future.
fixes https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/4518
This is a full switch, fs io operations are also tokio ones, working through
thread pool. Similar to pageserver, we have multiple runtimes for easier `top`
usage and isolation.
Notable points:
- Now that guts of safekeeper.rs are full of .await's, we need to be very
careful not to drop task at random point, leaving timeline in unclear
state. Currently the only writer is walreceiver and we don't have top
level cancellation there, so we are good. But to be safe probably we should
add a fuse panicking if task is being dropped while operation on a timeline
is in progress.
- Timeline lock is Tokio one now, as we do disk IO under it.
- Collecting metrics got a crutch: since prometheus Collector is
synchronous, it spawns a thread with current thread runtime collecting data.
- Anything involving closures becomes significantly more complicated, as
async fns are already kinda closures + 'async closures are unstable'.
- Main thread now tracks other main tasks, which got much easier.
- The only sync place left is initial data loading, as otherwise clippy
complains on timeline map lock being held across await points -- which is
not bad here as it happens only in single threaded runtime of main thread.
But having it sync doesn't hurt either.
I'm concerned about performance of thread pool io offloading, async traits and
many await points; but we can try and see how it goes.
fixes https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/3036
fixes https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/3966
The field means the same thing as the `wal_end` field in the XLogData
struct. And in the postgres-protocol crate's corresponding
PrimaryKeepAlive struct, it's also called `wal_end`. Let's be
consistent.
As noted by Arthur at
https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/pull/4144#pullrequestreview-1411031881
When a new connection is established to the safekeeper, the 'end_pos'
field is initially set to Lsn::INVALID (i.e 0/0). If there is no WAL to
send to the client, we send KeepAlive messages with Lsn::INVALID. That
confuses the pageserver: it thinks that safekeeper is lagging very much
behind the tip of the branch, and will reconnect to a different
safekeeper. Then the same thing happens with the new safekeeper, until
some WAL is streamed which sets 'end_pos' to a valid value.
This fix always sets `end_pos` to the most recent `commit_lsn` value.
This is useful to send the latest `commit_lsn` to the receiver, so it
will know how advanced this safekeeper compared to the others.
Fixes https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/3972
Supersedes https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/pull/4144
Refactors walsenders out of timeline.rs to makes it less convoluted into
separate WalSenders with its own lock, but otherwise having the same structure.
Tracking of in-memory remote_consistent_lsn is also moved there as it is mainly
received from pageserver.
State of walsender (feedback) is also restructured to be cleaner; now it is
either PageserverFeedback or StandbyFeedback(StandbyReply, HotStandbyFeedback),
but not both.
This is the the feedback originating from pageserver, so change previous
confusing names to
s/ReplicationFeedback/PageserverFeedback
s/ps_writelsn/last_receive_lsn
s/ps_flushlsn/disk_consistent_lsn
s/ps_apply_lsn/remote_consistent_lsn
I haven't changed on the wire format to keep compatibility. However,
understanding of new field names is added to compute, so once all computes
receive this patch we can change the wire names as well. Safekeepers/pageservers
are deployed roughly at the same time and it is ok to live without feedbacks
during the short period, so this is not a problem there.
- Add support for splitting async postgres_backend into read and write halfes.
Safekeeper needs this for bidirectional streams. To this end, encapsulate
reading-writing postgres messages to framed.rs with split support without any
additional changes (relying on BufRead for reading and BytesMut out buffer for
writing).
- Use async postgres_backend throughout safekeeper (and in proxy auth link
part).
- In both safekeeper COPY streams, do read-write from the same thread/task with
select! for easier error handling.
- Tidy up finishing CopyBoth streams in safekeeper sending and receiving WAL
-- join split parts back catching errors from them before returning.
Initially I hoped to do that read-write without split at all, through polling
IO:
https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/pull/3522
However that turned out to be more complicated than I initially expected
due to 1) borrow checking and 2) anon Future types. 1) required Rc<Refcell<...>>
which is Send construct just to satisfy the checker; 2) can be workaround with
transmute. But this is so messy that I decided to leave split.
To untie cyclic dependency between sync and async versions of postgres_backend,
copy QueryError and some logging/error routines to postgres_backend.rs. This is
temporal glue to make commits smaller, sync version will be dropped by the
upcoming commit completely.
Closes https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/3114
Adds more typization into errors that appear during protocol messages (`FeMessage`), postgres and walreceiver connections.
Socket IO errors are now better detected and logged with lesser (INFO, DEBUG) error level, without traces that they were logged before, when they were wrapped in anyhow context.
Changes:
* Remove `RemoteObjectId` concept from remote_storage.
Operate directly on /-separated names instead.
These names are now represented by struct `RemotePath` which was renamed from struct `RelativePath`
* Require remote storage to operate on relative paths for its contents, thus simplifying the way to derive them in pageserver and safekeeper
* Make `IndexPart` to use `String` instead of `RelativePath` for its entries, since those are just the layer names
- Split postgres_ffi into two version specific files.
- Preserve pg_version in timeline metadata.
- Use pg_version in safekeeper code. Check for postgres major version mismatch.
- Clean up the code to use DEFAULT_PG_VERSION constant everywhere, instead of hardcoding.
- Parameterize python tests: use DEFAULT_PG_VERSION env and pg_version fixture.
To run tests using a specific PostgreSQL version, pass the DEFAULT_PG_VERSION environment variable:
'DEFAULT_PG_VERSION='15' ./scripts/pytest test_runner/regress'
Currently don't all tests pass, because rust code relies on the default version of PostgreSQL in a few places.
Another preparatory commit for pg15 support:
* generate bindings for both pg14 and pg15;
* update Makefile and CI scripts: now neon build depends on both PostgreSQL versions;
* some code refactoring to decrease version-specific dependencies.
