## Problem
I discovered two bugs corresponding to safekeeper migration, which
together might lead to a data loss during the migration. The second bug
is from a hadron patch and might lead to a data loss during the
safekeeper restore in hadron as well.
1. `switch_membership` returns the current `term` instead of
`last_log_term`. It is used to choose the `sync_position` in the
algorithm, so we might choose the wrong one and break the correctness
guarantees.
2. The current `term` is used to choose the most advanced SK in
`pull_timeline` with higher priority than `flush_lsn`. It is incorrect
because the most advanced safekeeper is the one with the highest
`(last_log_term, flush_lsn)` pair. The compute might bump term on the
least advanced sk, making it the best choice to pull from, and thus
making committed log entries "uncommitted" after `pull_timeline`
Part of https://databricks.atlassian.net/browse/LKB-1017
## Summary of changes
- Return `last_log_term` in `switch_membership`
- Use `(last_log_term, flush_lsn)` as a primary key for choosing the
most advanced sk in `pull_timeline` and deny pulling if the `max_term`
is higher than on the most advanced sk (hadron only)
- Write tests for both cases
- Retry `sync_safekeepers` in `compute_ctl`
- Take into the account the quorum size when calculating `sync_position`
## Problem
With safekeeper migration in mind, we can now pull/exclude the timeline
multiple times within the same safekeeper. To avoid races between out of
order requests, we need to ignore the pull/exclude requests if we have
already seen a higher generation.
- Closes: https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/12186
- Closes: [LKB-949](https://databricks.atlassian.net/browse/LKB-949)
## Summary of changes
- Annotate timeline tombstones in safekeeper with request generation.
- Replace `ignore_tombstone` option with `mconf` in
`PullTimelineRequest`
- Switch membership in `pull_timeline` if the existing/pulled timeline
has an older generation.
- Refuse to switch membership if the timeline is being deleted
(`is_canceled`).
- Refuse to switch membership in compute greeting request if the
safekeeper is not a member of `mconf`.
- Pass `mconf` in `PullTimelineRequest` in safekeeper_service
---------
Co-authored-by: Arpad Müller <arpad-m@users.noreply.github.com>
## Problem
We don't detect if safekeeper migration fails after the the commiting
the membership configuration to the database. As a result, we might
leave stale timelines on excluded safekeepers and do not notify
cplane/safekepeers about new configuration.
- Implements solution proposed in
https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/pull/12432
- Closes: https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/12192
- Closes: [LKB-944](https://databricks.atlassian.net/browse/LKB-944)
## Summary of changes
- Add `sk_set_notified_generation` column to `timelines` database
- Update `*_notified_generation` in database during the finish state.
- Commit reconciliation requests to database atomically with membership
configuration.
- Reload pending ops and retry "finish" step if we detect
`*_notified_generation` mismatch.
- Add failpoints and test that we handle failures well
## Problem
We don't validate the validity of the `new_sk_set` before starting the
migration. It is validated later, so the migration to an invalid
safekeeper set will fail anyway. But at this point we might already
commited an invalid `new_sk_set` to the database and there is no `abort`
command yet (I ran into this issue in neon_local and ruined the timeline
:)
- Part of https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/11669
## Summary of changes
- Add safekeeper count and safekeeper duplication checks before starting
the migration
- Test that we validate the `new_sk_set` before starting the migration
- Add `force` option to the `TimelineSafekeeperMigrateRequest` to
disable not-mandatory checks
## Problem
Pageserver now writes errors in the log during the safekeeper migration.
Some errors are added to allowed errors, but "timeline not found in
global map" is not.
- Will be properly fixed in
https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/12191
## Summary of changes
Add "timeline not found in global map" error in a list of allowed errors
in `test_safekeeper_migration_simple`
## Problem
We don't notify cplane about safekeeper membership change yet. Without
the notification the compute needs to know all the safekeepers on the
cluster to be able to speak to them. Change notifications will allow to
avoid it.
- Closes: https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/12188
## Summary of changes
- Implement `notify_safekeepers` method in `ComputeHook`
- Notify cplane about safekeepers in `safekeeper_migrate` handler.
- Update the test to make sure notifications work.
## Out of scope
- There is `cplane_notified_generation` field in `timelines` table in
strocon's database. It's not needed now, so it's not updated in the PR.
Probably we can remove it.
- e2e tests to make sure it works with a production cplane
