## Problem
We don't validate the validity of the `new_sk_set` before starting the
migration. It is validated later, so the migration to an invalid
safekeeper set will fail anyway. But at this point we might already
commited an invalid `new_sk_set` to the database and there is no `abort`
command yet (I ran into this issue in neon_local and ruined the timeline
:)
- Part of https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/11669
## Summary of changes
- Add safekeeper count and safekeeper duplication checks before starting
the migration
- Test that we validate the `new_sk_set` before starting the migration
- Add `force` option to the `TimelineSafekeeperMigrateRequest` to
disable not-mandatory checks
# TLDR
Problem-I is a bug fix. The rest are no-ops.
## Problem I
Page server checks image layer creation based on the elapsed time but
this check depends on the current logical size, which is only computed
on shard 0. Thus, for non-0 shards, the check will be ineffective and
image creation will never be done for idle tenants.
## Summary of changes I
This PR fixes the problem by simply removing the dependency on current
logical size.
## Summary of changes II
This PR adds a timeout when calling page server to split shard to make
sure SC does not wait for the API call forever. Currently the PR doesn't
adds any retry logic because it's not clear whether page server shard
split can be safely retried if the existing operation is still ongoing
or left the storage in a bad state. Thus it's better to abort the whole
operation and restart.
## Problem III
`test_remote_failures` requires PS to be compiled in the testing mode.
For PS in dev/staging, they are compiled without this mode.
## Summary of changes III
Remove the restriction and also increase the number of total failures
allowed.
## Summary of changes IV
remove test on PS getpage http route.
---------
Co-authored-by: Chen Luo <chen.luo@databricks.com>
Co-authored-by: Yecheng Yang <carlton.yang@databricks.com>
Co-authored-by: Vlad Lazar <vlad@neon.tech>
Fixes [LKB-61](https://databricks.atlassian.net/browse/LKB-61):
`test_timeline_archival_chaos` being flaky with storcon error `Requested
tenant is missing`.
When a tenant migration is ongoing, and the attach request has been sent
to the new location, but the attach hasn't finished yet, it is possible
for the pageserver to return a 412 precondition failed HTTP error on
timeline deletion, because it is being sent to the new location already.
That one we would previously log via sth like:
```
ERROR request{method=DELETE path=/v1/tenant/1f544a11c90d1afd7af9b26e48985a4e/timeline/32818fb3ebf07cb7f06805429d7dee38 request_id=c493c04b-7f33-46d2-8a65-aac8a5516055}: Error processing HTTP request: InternalServerError(Error deleting timeline 32
818fb3ebf07cb7f06805429d7dee38 on 1f544a11c90d1afd7af9b26e48985a4e on node 2 (localhost): pageserver API: Precondition failed: Requested tenant is missing
```
This patch changes that and makes us return a more reasonable resource
unavailable error. Not sure how scalable this is with tenants with a
large number of shards, but that's a different discussion (we'd probably
need a limited amount of per-storcon retries).
example
[link](https://neon-github-public-dev.s3.amazonaws.com/reports/pr-12398/15981821532/index.html#/testresult/e7785dfb1238d92f).
This is a no-op for the neon deployment
* Introduce the concept image consistent lsn: of the largest LSN below
which all pages have been redone successfully
* Use the image consistent LSN for forced image layer creations
* Optionally expose the image consistent LSN via the timeline describe
HTTP endpoint
* Add a sharded timeline describe endpoint to storcon
---------
Co-authored-by: Chen Luo <chen.luo@databricks.com>
## Problem
We have a `safekeeper_migrate` handler, but no subcommand in
`storcon_cli`. Same for `/:timeline_id/locate` for identifying current
set of safekeepers.
- Closes: https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/12395
## Summary of changes
- Add `timeline-safekeeper-migrate` and `timeline-locate` subcommands to
`storcon_cli`
## Problem
close LKB-253
## Summary of changes
404 for timeline requests could happen when the tenant is intended to be
on a pageserver but not attached yet. This patch adds handling for the
lease request. In the future, we should extend this handling to more
operations.
---------
Signed-off-by: Alex Chi Z <chi@neon.tech>
## Problem
close LKB-199
## Summary of changes
We always return the error as 500 to the cplane if a LSN lease request
fails. This cause issues for the cplane as they don't retry on 500. This
patch correctly passes through the error and assign the error code so
that cplane can know if it is a retryable error. (TODO: look at the
cplane code and learn the retry logic).
Note that this patch does not resolve LKB-253 -- we need to handle not
found error separately in the lsn lease path, like wait until the tenant
gets attached, or return 503 so that cplane can retry.
---------
Signed-off-by: Alex Chi Z <chi@neon.tech>
The `--timelines-onto-safekeepers` flag is very consequential in the
sense that it controls every single timeline creation. However, we don't
have any automatic insight whether enabling the option will break things
or not.
The main way things can break is by misconfigured safekeepers, say they
are marked as paused in the storcon db. The best input so far we can
obtain via manually connecting via storcon_cli and listing safekeepers,
but this is cumbersome and manual so prone to human error.
So at storcon startup, do a simulated "test creation" in which we call
`timelines_onto_safekeepers` with the configuration provided to us, and
print whether it was successful or not. No actual timeline is created,
and nothing is written into the storcon db. The heartbeat info will not
have reached us at that point yet, but that's okay, because we still
fall back to safekeepers that don't have any heartbeat.
Also print some general scheduling policy stats on initial safekeeper
load.
Part of #11670.
## Problem
Deletion process does not calculate preferred nodes correctly - it
doesn't consider current tenant-shard layout among all pageservers.
## Summary of changes
- Added a schedule context calculation for node deletion
Co-authored-by: Aleksandr Sarantsev <aleksandr.sarantsev@databricks.com>
## Problem
Names are not consistent between safekeeper migration RFC and the actual
implementation.
It's not used anywhere in production yet, so it's safe to rename. We
don't need to worry about backward compatibility.
- Follow up on https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/pull/12432
## Summary of changes
- rename term -> last_log_term in TimelineMembershipSwitchResponse
- add missing fields to TimelineMembershipSwitchResponse in python
## Problem
The current deletion operation is synchronous and blocking, which is
unsuitable for potentially long-running tasks like. In such cases, the
standard HTTP request-response pattern is not a good fit.
## Summary of Changes
- Added new `storcon_cli` commands: `NodeStartDelete` and
`NodeCancelDelete` to initiate and cancel deletion asynchronously.
- Added corresponding `storcon` HTTP handlers to support the new
start/cancel deletion flow.
- Introduced a new type of background operation: `Delete`, to track and
manage the deletion process outside the request lifecycle.
---------
Co-authored-by: Aleksandr Sarantsev <aleksandr.sarantsev@databricks.com>
When deploying new safekeepers, we don't immediately want to send
traffic to them. Maybe they are not ready yet by the time the deploy
script is registering them with the storage controller.
For pageservers, the storcon solves the problem by not scheduling stuff
to them unless there has been a positive heartbeat response. We can't do
the same for safekeepers though, otherwise a single down safekeeper
would mean we can't create new timelines in smaller regions where there
is only three safekeepers in total.
So far we have created safekeepers as `pause` but this adds a manual
step to safekeeper deployment which is prone to oversight. We want
things to be automatted. So we introduce a new state `activating` that
acts just like `pause`, except that we automatically transition the
policy to `active` once we get a positive heartbeat from the safekeeper.
For `pause`, we always keep the safekeeper paused.
## Problem
Currently, if `storcon` (storage controller) reconciliations repeatedly
fail, the system will indefinitely freeze optimizations. This can result
in optimization starvation for several days until the reconciliation
issues are manually resolved. To mitigate this, we should detect
persistently failing reconciliations and exclude them from influencing
the optimization decision.
## Summary of Changes
- A tenant shard reconciliation is now considered "keep-failing" if it
fails 5 consecutive times. These failures are excluded from the
optimization readiness check.
- Added a new metric: `storage_controller_keep_failing_reconciles` to
monitor such cases.
- Added a warning log message when a reconciliation is marked as
"keep-failing".
---------
Co-authored-by: Aleksandr Sarantsev <aleksandr.sarantsev@databricks.com>
## Problem
We don't notify cplane about safekeeper membership change yet. Without
the notification the compute needs to know all the safekeepers on the
cluster to be able to speak to them. Change notifications will allow to
avoid it.
- Closes: https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/12188
## Summary of changes
- Implement `notify_safekeepers` method in `ComputeHook`
- Notify cplane about safekeepers in `safekeeper_migrate` handler.
- Update the test to make sure notifications work.
## Out of scope
- There is `cplane_notified_generation` field in `timelines` table in
strocon's database. It's not needed now, so it's not updated in the PR.
Probably we can remove it.
- e2e tests to make sure it works with a production cplane
## Problem
The gRPC API does not provide LSN leases.
## Summary of changes
* Add LSN lease support to the gRPC API.
* Use gRPC LSN leases for static computes with `grpc://` connstrings.
* Move `PageserverProtocol` into the `compute_api::spec` module and
reuse it.
## Problem
Similarly to #12217, the following endpoints may result in a stripe size
mismatch between the storage controller and Pageserver if an unsharded
tenant has a different stripe size set than the default. This can lead
to data corruption if the tenant is later manually split without
specifying an explicit stripe size, since the storage controller and
Pageserver will apply different defaults. This commonly happens with
tenants that were created before the default stripe size was changed
from 32k to 2k.
* `PUT /v1/tenant/config`
* `PATCH /v1/tenant/config`
These endpoints are no longer in regular production use (they were used
when cplane still managed Pageserver directly), but can still be called
manually or by tests.
## Summary of changes
Retain the current shard parameters when updating the location config in
`PUT | PATCH /v1/tenant/config`.
Also opportunistically derive `Copy` for `ShardParameters`.
## Problem
Some of the design decisions in PR #12256 were influenced by the
requirements of consistency tests. These decisions introduced
intermediate logic that is no longer needed and should be cleaned up.
## Summary of Changes
- Remove the `feature("testing")` flag related to
`kick_secondary_download`.
- Set the default value of `kick_secondary_download` back to false,
reflecting the intended production behavior.
Co-authored-by: Aleksandr Sarantsev <aleksandr.sarantsev@databricks.com>
Add a new 'pageserver_connection_info' field in the compute spec. It
replaces the old 'pageserver_connstring' field with a more complicated
struct that includes both libpq and grpc URLs, for each shard (or only
one of the the URLs, depending on the configuration). It also includes
a flag suggesting which one to use; compute_ctl now uses it to decide
which protocol to use for the basebackup.
This is compatible with everything that's in production, because the
control plane never used the 'pageserver_connstring' field. That was
added a long time ago with the idea that it would replace the code
that digs the 'neon.pageserver_connstring' GUC from the list of
Postgres settings, but we never got around to do that in the control
plane. Hence, it was only used with neon_local. But the plan now is to
pass the 'pageserver_connection_info' from the control plane, and once
that's fully deployed everywhere, the code to parse
'neon.pageserver_connstring' in compute_ctl can be removed.
The 'grpc' flag on an endpoint in endpoint config is now more of a
suggestion. Compute_ctl gets both URLs, so it can choose to use libpq
or grpc as it wishes. It currently always obeys the 'prefer_grpc' flag
that's part of the connection info though. Postgres however uses grpc
iff the new rust-based communicator is enabled.
TODO/plan for the control plane:
- Start to pass `pageserver_connection_info` in the spec file.
- Also keep the current `neon.pageserver_connstring` setting for now,
for backwards compatibility with old computes
After that, the `pageserver_connection_info.prefer_grpc` flag in the
spec file can be used to control whether compute_ctl uses grpc or
libpq. The actual compute's grpc usage will be controlled by the
`neon.enable_new_communicator` GUC. It can be set separately from
'prefer_grpc'.
Later:
- Once all old computes are gone, remove the code to pass
`neon.pageserver_connstring`
## Problem
- Closes: https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/12298
## Summary of changes
- Set `timeline_safekeeper_count` in `neon_local` if we have less than 3
safekeepers
- Remove `cfg!(feature = "testing")` code from
`safekeepers_for_new_timeline`
- Change `timeline_safekeeper_count` type to `usize`
## Problem
In our infra config, we have to split server_api_key and other fields in
two files: the former one in the sops file, and the latter one in the
normal config. It creates the situation that we might misconfigure some
regions that it only has part of the fields available, causing
storcon/pageserver refuse to start.
## Summary of changes
Allow PostHog config to have part of the fields available. Parse it
later.
Signed-off-by: Alex Chi Z <chi@neon.tech>
## Problem
part of https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/11813
## Summary of changes
It costs $$$ to directly retrieve the feature flags from the pageserver.
Therefore, this patch adds new APIs to retrieve the spec from the
storcon and updates it via pageserver.
* Storcon retrieves the feature flag and send it to the pageservers.
* If the feature flag gets updated outside of the normal refresh loop of
the pageserver, pageserver won't fetch the flags on its own as long as
the last updated time <= refresh_period.
Signed-off-by: Alex Chi Z <chi@neon.tech>
This makes it possible for the compiler to validate that a match block
matched all PostgreSQL versions we support.
## Problem
We did not have a complete picture about which places we had to test
against PG versions, and what format these versions were: The full PG
version ID format (Major/minor/bugfix `MMmmbb`) as transfered in
protocol messages, or only the Major release version (`MM`). This meant
type confusion was rampant.
With this change, it becomes easier to develop new version-dependent
features, by making type and niche confusion impossible.
## Summary of changes
Every use of `pg_version` is now typed as either `PgVersionId` (u32,
valued in decimal `MMmmbb`) or PgMajorVersion (an enum, with a value for
every major version we support, serialized and stored like a u32 with
the value of that major version)
---------
Co-authored-by: Arpad Müller <arpad-m@users.noreply.github.com>
The 1.88.0 stable release is near (this Thursday). We'd like to fix most
warnings beforehand so that the compiler upgrade doesn't require
approval from too many teams.
This is therefore a preparation PR (like similar PRs before it).
There is a lot of changes for this release, mostly because the
`uninlined_format_args` lint has been added to the `style` lint group.
One can read more about the lint
[here](https://rust-lang.github.io/rust-clippy/master/#/uninlined_format_args).
The PR is the result of `cargo +beta clippy --fix` and `cargo fmt`. One
remaining warning is left for the proxy team.
---------
Co-authored-by: Conrad Ludgate <conrad@neon.tech>
## Problem
`Attached(0)` tenant migrations can get stuck if the heatmap file has
not been uploaded.
## Summary of Changes
- Added a test to reproduce the issue.
- Introduced a `kick_secondary_downloads` config flag:
- Enabled in testing environments.
- Disabled in production (and in the new test).
- Updated `Attached(0)` locations to consider the number of secondaries
in their intent when deciding whether to download the heatmap.
## Problem
The scheduler uses total shards per AZ to select the AZ for newly
created or attached tenants.
This makes bad decisions when we have different node counts per AZ -- we
might have 2 very busy pageservers in one AZ, and 4 more lightly loaded
pageservers in other AZs, and the scheduler picks the busy pageservers
because the total shard count in their AZ is lower.
## Summary of changes
- Divide the shard count by the number of nodes in the AZ when scoring
in `get_az_for_new_tenant`
---------
Co-authored-by: John Spray <john.spray@databricks.com>
## Problem
We need to specify the number of safekeepers for neon_local without
`testing` feature.
Also we need this option for testing different configurations of
safekeeper migration code.
We cannot set it in `neon_fixtures.py` and in the default config of
`neon_local` yet, because it will fail compatibility tests. I'll make a
separate PR with removing `cfg!("testing")` completely and specifying
this option in the config when this option reaches the release branch.
- Part of https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/12298
## Summary of changes
- Add `timeline_safekeeper_count` config option to storcon and
neon_local
## Problem
`test_sharding_failures` is flaky due to interference from the
`background_reconcile` process.
The details are in the issue
https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/12029.
## Summary of changes
- Use `reconcile_until_idle` to ensure a stable state before running
test assertions
- Added error tolerance in `reconcile_until_idle` test function (Failure
cases: 1, 3, 19, 20)
- Ignore the `Keeping extra secondaries` warning message since it i
retryable (Failure case: 2)
- Deduplicated code in `assert_rolled_back` and `assert_split_done`
- Added a log message before printing plenty of Node `X` seen on
pageserver `Y`
## Problem
`neon_local` should support endpoints using gRPC, by providing `grpc://`
connstrings with the Pageservers' gRPC ports.
Requires #12268.
Touches #11926.
## Summary of changes
* Add `--grpc` switch for `neon_local endpoint create`.
* Generate `grpc://` connstrings for endpoints when enabled.
Computes don't actually support `grpc://` connstrings yet, but will
soon.
gRPC is configured when the endpoint is created, not when it's started,
such that it continues to use gRPC across restarts and reconfigurations.
In particular, this is necessary for the storage controller's local
notify hook, which can't easily plumb through gRPC configuration from
the start/reconfigure commands but has access to the endpoint's
configuration.
## Problem
The metrics `storage_controller_safekeeper_request_error` and
`storage_controller_safekeeper_request_latency` currently use
`pageserver_id` as a label.
This can be misleading, as the metrics are about safekeeper requests.
We want to replace this with a more accurate label — either
`safekeeper_id` or `node_id`.
## Summary of changes
- Introduced `SafekeeperRequestLabelGroup` with `safekeeper_id`.
- Updated the affected metrics to use the new label group.
- Fixed incorrect metric usage in safekeeper_client.rs
## Follow-up
- Review usage of these metrics in alerting rules and existing Grafana
dashboards to ensure this change does not break something.
## Problem
Pageservers now expose a gRPC API on a separate address and port. This
must be registered with the storage controller such that it can be
plumbed through to the compute via cplane.
Touches #11926.
## Summary of changes
This patch registers the gRPC address and port with the storage
controller:
* Add gRPC address to `nodes` database table and `NodePersistence`, with
a Diesel migration.
* Add gRPC address in `NodeMetadata`, `NodeRegisterRequest`,
`NodeDescribeResponse`, and `TenantLocateResponseShard`.
* Add gRPC address flags to `storcon_cli node-register`.
These changes are backwards-compatible, since all structs will ignore
unknown fields during deserialization.
## Problem
The `stably_attached` function is hard to read due to deeply nested
conditionals
## Summary of Changes
- Refactored `stably_attached` to use early returns and the `?` operator
for improved readability
## Problem
If the node intent includes more than one secondary, we can generate a
replace optimization using a candidate node that is already a secondary
location.
## Summary of changes
- Exclude all other secondary nodes from the scoring process to ensure
optimal candidate selection.
## Problem
Comment for `storage_controller_reconcile_long_running` metric was
copy-pasted and not updated in #9207
## Summary of changes
- Fixed comment
## Problem
Comment is in incorrect place: `/metrics` code is above its description
comment.
## Summary of changes
- `/metrics` code is now below the comment
## Problem
Need to fix naming `safkeeper` -> `safekeeper`
## Summary of changes
- `storage_controller_safkeeper_reconciles_*` renamed to
`storage_controller_safekeeper_reconciles_*`
## Problem
ChaosInjector is intended to skip non-active scheduling policies, but
the current logic skips active shards instead.
## Summary of changes
- Fixed shard eligibility condition to correctly allow chaos injection
for shards with an Active scheduling policy.
## Problem
`test_historic_storage_formats` uses `/tenant_import` to import historic
data. Tenant import does not create timelines onto safekeepers, because
they might already exist on some safekeeper set. If it does, then we may
end up with two different quorums accepting WAL for the same timeline.
If the tenant import is used in a real deployment, the administrator is
responsible for looking for the proper safekeeper set and migrate
timelines into storcon-managed timelines.
- Relates to https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/pull/11712
## Summary of changes
- Create timelines onto safekeepers manually after tenant import in
`test_historic_storage_formats`
- Add a note to tenant import that timelines will be not storcon-managed
after the import.
## Problem
The location config (which includes the stripe size) is stored on
pageserver disk.
For unsharded tenants we [do not include the shard identity in the
serialized
description](ad88ec9257/pageserver/src/tenant/config.rs (L64-L66)).
When the pageserver restarts, it reads that configuration and will use
the stripe size from there
and rely on storcon input from reattach for generation and mode.
The default deserialization is ShardIdentity::unsharded. This has the
new default stripe size of 2048.
Hence, for unsharded tenants we can be running with a stripe size
different from that the one in the
storcon observed state. This is not a problem until we shard split
without specifying a stripe size (i.e. manual splits via the UI or
storcon_cli). When that happens the new shards will use the 2048 stripe
size until storcon realises and switches them back. At that point it's
too late, since we've ingested data with the wrong stripe sizes.
## Summary of changes
Ideally, we would always have the full shard identity on disk. To
achieve this over two releases we do:
1. Always persist the shard identity in the location config on the PS.
2. Storage controller includes the stripe size to use in the re attach
response.
After the first release, we will start persisting correct stripe sizes
for any tenant shard that the storage controller
explicitly sends a location_conf. After the second release, the
re-attach change kicks in and we'll persist the
shard identity for all shards.
## Problem
Compatibility tests may be run against a compatibility snapshot
generated with `--timelines-onto-safekeepers=false`. We need to start
the compute without a generation (or with 0 generation) if the timeline
is not storcon-managed, otherwise the compute will hang.
This handler is needed to check if the timeline is storcon-managed.
It's also needed for better test coverage of safekeeper migration code.
- Relates to https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/pull/11712
## Summary of changes
- Implement `tenant_timeline_locate` handler in storcon to get
safekeeper info from storcon's DB
