I suspected a wakeup could be lost with
`remote_storage::support::DownloadStream` if the cancellation and inner
stream wakeups happen simultaneously. The next poll would only return
the cancellation error without setting the wakeup. There is no lost
wakeup because the single future for getting the cancellation error is
consumed when the value is ready, and a new future is created for the
*next* value. The new future is always polled. Similarly, if only the
`Stream::poll_next` is being used after a `Some(_)` value has been
yielded, it makes no sense to have an expectation of a wakeup for the
*(N+1)th* stream value already set because when a value is wanted,
`Stream::poll_next` will be called.
A test is added to show that the above is true.
Additionally, there was a question of these cancellations and timeouts
flowing to attached or secondary tenant downloads. A test is added to
show that this, in fact, happens.
Lastly, a warning message is logged when a download stream is polled
after a timeout or cancellation error (currently unexpected) so we can
rule it out while troubleshooting.
As noticed in #6836 some occurances of error conversions were missed in
#6697:
- `std::io::Error` popped up by `tokio::io::copy_buf` containing
`DownloadError` was turned into `DownloadError::Other`
- similarly for secondary downloader errors
These changes come at the loss of pathname context.
Cc: #6096
Cancellation and timeouts are handled at remote_storage callsites, if
they are. However they should always be handled, because we've had
transient problems with remote storage connections.
- Add cancellation token to the `trait RemoteStorage` methods
- For `download*`, `list*` methods there is
`DownloadError::{Cancelled,Timeout}`
- For the rest now using `anyhow::Error`, it will have root cause
`remote_storage::TimeoutOrCancel::{Cancel,Timeout}`
- Both types have `::is_permanent` equivalent which should be passed to
`backoff::retry`
- New generic RemoteStorageConfig option `timeout`, defaults to 120s
- Start counting timeouts only after acquiring concurrency limiter
permit
- Cancellable permit acquiring
- Download stream timeout or cancellation is communicated via an
`std::io::Error`
- Exit backoff::retry by marking cancellation errors permanent
Fixes: #6096Closes: #4781
Co-authored-by: arpad-m <arpad-m@users.noreply.github.com>
This PR is preliminary cleanups and refactoring around `remote_storage`
for next PR which will move the timeouts and cancellation into
`remote_storage`.
Summary:
- smaller drive-by fixes
- code simplification
- refactor common parts like `DownloadError::is_permanent`
- align error types with `RemoteStorage::list_*` to use more
`download_retry` helper
Cc: #6096
