## Problem
1. During the rollout we got a panic: "timeline that we were deleting
was concurrently removed from 'timelines' map" that was caused by lock
guard not being propagated to the background part of the deletion.
Existing test didnt catch it because failpoint that was used for
verification was placed earlier prior to background task spawning.
2. When looking at surrounding code one more bug was detected. We
removed timeline from the map before deletion is finished, which breaks
client retry logic, because it will indicate 404 before actual deletion
is completed which can lead to client stopping its retry poll earlier.
## Summary of changes
1. Carry the lock guard over to background deletion. Ensure existing
test case fails without applied patch (second deletion becomes stuck
without it, which eventually leads to a test failure).
2. Move delete_all call earlier so timeline is removed from the map is
the last thing done during deletion.
Additionally I've added timeline_id to the `update_gc_info` span,
because `debug_assert_current_span_has_tenant_and_timeline_id` in
`download_remote_layer` was firing when `update_gc_info` lead to
on-demand downloads via `find_lsn_for_timestamp` (caught by @problame).
This is not directly related to the PR but fixes possible flakiness.
Another smaller set of changes involves deletion wrapper used in python
tests. Now there is a simpler wrapper that waits for deletions to
complete `timeline_delete_wait_completed`. Most of the
test_delete_timeline.py tests make negative tests, i.e., "does
ps_http.timeline_delete() fail in this and that scenario".
These can be left alone. Other places when we actually do the deletions,
we need to use the helper that polls for completion.
Discussion
https://neondb.slack.com/archives/C03F5SM1N02/p1686668007396639resolves#4496
---------
Co-authored-by: Christian Schwarz <christian@neon.tech>
We use the term "endpoint" in for compute Postgres nodes in the web UI
and user-facing documentation now. Adjust the nomenclature in the code.
This changes the name of the "neon_local pg" command to "neon_local
endpoint". Also adjust names of classes, variables etc. in the python
tests accordingly.
This also changes the directory structure so that endpoints are now
stored in:
.neon/endpoints/<endpoint id>
instead of:
.neon/pgdatadirs/tenants/<tenant_id>/<endpoint (node) name>
The tenant ID is no longer part of the path. That means that you
cannot have two endpoints with the same name/ID in two different
tenants anymore. That's consistent with how we treat endpoints in the
real control plane and proxy: the endpoint ID must be globally unique.
Reason and backtrace are added to the Broken state. Backtrace is automatically collected when tenant entered the broken state. The format for API, CLI and metrics is changed and unified to return tenant state name in camel case. Previously snake case was used for metrics and camel case was used for everything else. Now tenant state field in TenantInfo swagger spec is changed to contain state name in "slug" field and other fields (currently only reason and backtrace for Broken variant in "data" field). To allow for this breaking change state was removed from TenantInfo swagger spec because it was not used anywhere.
Please note that the tenant's broken reason is not persisted on disk so the reason is lost when pageserver is restarted.
Requires changes to grafana dashboard that monitors tenant states.
Closes#3001
---------
Co-authored-by: theirix <theirix@gmail.com>
- use parse_metrics() in all places where we parse Prometheus metrics
- query_all: make `filter` argument optional
- encourage using properly parsed, typed metrics by changing get_metrics()
to return already-parsed metrics. The new get_metric_str() method,
like in the Safekeeper type, returns the raw text response.
The code in this change was extracted from #2595 (Heikki’s on-demand
download draft PR).
High-Level Changes
- New RemoteLayer Type
- On-Demand Download As An Effect Of Page Reconstruction
- Breaking Semantics For Physical Size Metrics
There are several follow-up work items planned.
Refer to the Epic issue on GitHub: https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/2029
closes https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/pull/3013
Co-authored-by: Kirill Bulatov <kirill@neon.tech>
Co-authored-by: Christian Schwarz <christian@neon.tech>
New RemoteLayer Type
====================
Instead of downloading all layers during tenant attach, we create
RemoteLayer instances for each of them and add them to the layer map.
On-Demand Download As An Effect Of Page Reconstruction
======================================================
At the heart of pageserver is Timeline::get_reconstruct_data(). It
traverses the layer map until it has collected all the data it needs to
produce the page image. Most code in the code base uses it, though many
layers of indirection.
Before this patch, the function would use synchronous filesystem IO to
load data from disk-resident layer files if the data was not cached.
That is not possible with RemoteLayer, because the layer file has not
been downloaded yet. So, we do the download when get_reconstruct_data
gets there, i.e., “on demand”.
The mechanics of how the download is done are rather involved, because
of the infamous async-sync-async sandwich problem that plagues the async
Rust world. We use the new PageReconstructResult type to work around
this. Its introduction is the cause for a good amount of code churn in
this patch. Refer to the block comment on `with_ondemand_download()`
for details.
Breaking Semantics For Physical Size Metrics
============================================
We rename prometheus metric pageserver_{current,resident}_physical_size to
reflect what this metric actually represents with on-demand download.
This intentionally BREAKS existing grafana dashboard and the cost model data
pipeline. Breaking is desirable because the meaning of this metrics has changed
with on-demand download. See
https://docs.google.com/document/d/12AFpvKY-7FZdR5a4CaD6Ir_rI3QokdCLSPJ6upHxJBo/edit#
for how we will handle this breakage.
Likewise, we rename the new billing_metrics’s PhysicalSize => ResidentSize.
This is not yet used anywhere, so, this is not a breaking change.
There is still a field called TimelineInfo::current_physical_size. It
is now the sum of the layer sizes in layer map, regardless of whether
local or remote. To compute that sum, we added a new trait method
PersistentLayer::file_size().
When updating the Python tests, we got rid of
current_physical_size_non_incremental. An earlier commit removed it from
the OpenAPI spec already, so this is not a breaking change.
test_timeline_size.py has grown additional assertions on the
resident_physical_size metric.
The code in this change was extracted from PR #2595, i.e., Heikki’s draft
PR for on-demand download.
High-Level Changes
- storage_sync module rewrite
- Changes to Tenant Loading
- Changes to Timeline States
- Crash-safe & Resumable Tenant Attach
There are several follow-up work items planned.
Refer to the Epic issue on GitHub:
https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/2029
Metadata:
closes https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/pull/2785
unsquashed history of this patch: archive/pr-2785-storage-sync2/pre-squash
Co-authored-by: Dmitry Rodionov <dmitry@neon.tech>
Co-authored-by: Christian Schwarz <christian@neon.tech>
===============================================================================
storage_sync module rewrite
===========================
The storage_sync code is rewritten. New module name is storage_sync2, mostly to
make a more reasonable git diff.
The updated block comment in storage_sync2.rs describes the changes quite well,
so, we will not reproduce that comment here. TL;DR:
- Global sync queue and RemoteIndex are replaced with per-timeline
`RemoteTimelineClient` structure that contains a queue for UploadOperations
to ensure proper ordering and necessary metadata.
- Before deleting local layer files, wait for ongoing UploadOps to finish
(wait_completion()).
- Download operations are not queued and executed immediately.
Changes to Tenant Loading
=========================
Initial sync part was rewritten as well and represents the other major change
that serves as a foundation for on-demand downloads. Routines for attaching and
loading shifted directly to Tenant struct and now are asynchronous and spawned
into the background.
Since this patch doesn’t introduce on-demand download of layers we fully
synchronize with the remote during pageserver startup. See details in
`Timeline::reconcile_with_remote` and `Timeline::download_missing`.
Changes to Tenant States
========================
The “Active” state has lost its “background_jobs_running: bool” member. That
variable indicated whether the GC & Compaction background loops are spawned or
not. With this patch, they are now always spawned. Unit tests (#[test]) use the
TenantConf::{gc_period,compaction_period} to disable their effect (15db566).
This patch introduces a new tenant state, “Attaching”. A tenant that is being
attached starts in this state and transitions to “Active” once it finishes
download.
The `GET /tenant` endpoints returns `TenantInfo::has_in_progress_downloads`. We
derive the value for that field from the tenant state now, to remain
backwards-compatible with cloud.git. We will remove that field when we switch
to on-demand downloads.
Changes to Timeline States
==========================
The TimelineInfo::awaits_download field is now equivalent to the tenant being
in Attaching state. Previously, download progress was tracked per timeline.
With this change, it’s only tracked per tenant. When on-demand downloads
arrive, the field will be completely obsolete. Deprecation is tracked in
isuse #2930.
Crash-safe & Resumable Tenant Attach
====================================
Previously, the attach operation was not persistent. I.e., when tenant attach
was interrupted by a crash, the pageserver would not continue attaching after
pageserver restart. In fact, the half-finished tenant directory on disk would
simply be skipped by tenant_mgr because it lacked the metadata file (it’s
written last). This patch introduces an “attaching” marker file inside that is
present inside the tenant directory while the tenant is attaching. During
pageserver startup, tenant_mgr will resume attach if that file is present. If
not, it assumes that the local tenant state is consistent and tries to load the
tenant. If that fails, the tenant transitions into Broken state.
Instead of spawning helper threads, we now use Tokio tasks. There
are multiple Tokio runtimes, for different kinds of tasks. One for
serving libpq client connections, another for background operations
like GC and compaction, and so on. That's not strictly required, we
could use just one runtime, but with this you can still get an
overview of what's happening with "top -H".
There's one subtle behavior in how TenantState is updated. Before this
patch, if you deleted all timelines from a tenant, its GC and
compaction loops were stopped, and the tenant went back to Idle
state. We no longer do that. The empty tenant stays Active. The
changes to test_tenant_tasks.py are related to that.
There's still plenty of synchronous code and blocking. For example, we
still use blocking std::io functions for all file I/O, and the
communication with WAL redo processes is still uses low-level unix
poll(). We might want to rewrite those later, but this will do for
now. The model is that local file I/O is considered to be fast enough
that blocking - and preventing other tasks running in the same thread -
is acceptable.
For better ergonomics. I always found it weird that we used UUID to
actually mean a tenant or timeline ID. It worked because it happened
to have the same length, 16 bytes, but it was hacky.
Merge batch_others and batch_pg_regress. The original idea was to
split all the python tests into multiple "batches" and run each batch
in parallel as a separate CI job. However, the batch_pg_regress batch
was pretty short compared to all the tests in batch_others. We could
split batch_others into multiple batches, but it actually seems better
to just treat them as one big pool of tests and use pytest's handle
the parallelism on its own. If we need to split them across multiple
nodes in the future, we could use pytest-shard or something else,
instead of managing the batches ourselves.
Merge test_neon_regress.py, test_pg_regress.py and test_isolation.py
into one file, test_pg_regress.py. Seems more clear to group all
pg_regress-based tests into one file, now that they would all be in
the same directory.
