Files
neon/pageserver
Christian Schwarz 8a042fb8ed refactor(compaction): eliminate CompactionError::Offload variant, map to ::Other (#12505)
Looks can be deceiving: the match blocks in
`maybe_trip_compaction_breaker`
and at the end of `compact_with_options` seem like differentiated error
handling, but in reality, these branches are unreachable at runtime
because the only source of `CompactionError::Offload` within the
compaction code is at the end of `Tenant::compaction_iteration`.

We can simply map offload cancellation to CompactionError::Cancelled and
all other offload errors to ::Other, since there's no differentiated
handling for them in the compaction code.

Also, the OffloadError::RemoteStorage variant has no differentiated
handling, but was wrapping the remote storage anyhow::Error in a
`anyhow(thiserror(anyhow))` sandwich. This PR removes that variant,
mapping all RemoteStorage errors to `OffloadError::Other`.
Thereby, the sandwich is gone and we will get a proper anyhow backtrace
to the remote storage error location if when we debug-print the
OffloadError (or the CompactionError if we map it to that).

refs
- https://databricks.atlassian.net/browse/LKB-182
- the observation that there's no need for differentiated handling of
CompactionError::Offload was made in
https://databricks.slack.com/archives/C09254R641L/p1751286453930269?thread_ts=1751284317.955159&cid=C09254R641L
2025-07-08 15:03:32 +00:00
..