# Stale-reference animation options [View the temporary image comparison Gist](https://gist.github.com/OrcaWin/5e39ef4c8975d13bda6a2c79a6c904a7). These captures record the options reviewed before implementation. **Option C, metadata-only shimmer, was selected.** | Option | Treatment | Tradeoff | | ---------------- | ------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------- | | A | Current whole-row shimmer | Most noticeable; also animates the surface. | | B | Title and metadata text shimmer | Closest to the requested effect; keeps icons and the surface steady. | | **C — selected** | **Metadata text shimmer** | Quieter; the title stays steady while scanning. | | D | Still baseline | Least distracting; no visible freshness cue. | B and C use shadcn's [official shimmer utility](https://ui.shadcn.com/docs/utils/shimmer), a pure-CSS text effect with RTL and reduced-motion support. Its [MIT-licensed source](https://github.com/shadcn-ui/ui/blob/main/packages/shadcn/src/tailwind.css) was checked on 23 October 2026. This does not require a React animation component. [AI Elements Shimmer](https://ai-sdk.dev/elements/components/shimmer) is a more configurable React/Motion alternative. The third-party [shadcn.io Shimmering Text](https://www.shadcn.io/text/shimmering-text) uses character animations and optional waves, which are unnecessary for these truncated titles. The comparison Gist preserves the earlier row and text treatments. The final implementation uses metadata-only shimmer. The standalone HTML report was a throw-away design artifact and is excluded from the final change. All four previews were checked through Playwright CDP in a hidden Electron renderer: identical 367px card heights before/after clearing stale state, light/dark at 320px and 430px, controls, OS/manual reduced motion, and no page overflow at 375px. The two stale rows alone animate. Text variants leave check icons unchanged. ![Dark comparison](dark-comparison.png) ![Light comparison](light-comparison.png)