Files
Jinwoo Hong 12d744f253 fix(skills): keep computer-use off filesystem and shell tasks (#21069)
* fix(skills): keep computer-use off filesystem and shell tasks

STA-7615: "On my desktop create a folder" was matching computer-use because
discovery copy said OS/window-level and neighboring skills advertised desktop UI.
Scope the trigger to visible GUI with no CLI path, and exclude files/folders/git/shell.

* fix(skills): prefer programmatic paths over computer-use

State the last-resort rule in discovery copy instead of enumerating
files/folders/git/shell. computer-use prefers shell, filesystem, git, HTTP,
CLIs, and Playwright/CDP; neighboring skills route to Computer Use only when
a visible window needs GUI control those cannot do.

* fix(skills): stop advertising computer-use from orchestration

Orchestration coordinates workers; it does not drive a GUI. Drop Computer Use
and Playwright/embedded-browser routing from its discovery description so
those tools are not pulled in from a coordination skill.

* fix(skills): drop Playwright from orca-cli discovery

orca-cli should not prescribe Playwright or CDP. Those tools may not be
installed, and page automation is not this skill's job.

* fix(skills): drop the page-only ban from computer-use discovery

Page automation is a preference, not a prohibition. If Playwright or CDP is
not available, a visible browser window is valid Computer Use. Keep the
hard split for Orca's embedded browser (`orca-cli`) only.
2026-09-16 15:43:11 -04:00

11 KiB

name, description
name description
computer-use Drives the GUI of a visible local app window through `orca computer`: accessibility tree, clicks, typing, menus, dialogs, and screenshots in native apps and external browser windows (Chrome, Edge, Safari) or webviews. Prefer a programmatic path (shell, filesystem, git, HTTP, existing CLIs) whenever it can complete the task. Use only when a visible window needs GUI control those cannot reach. Do not use for Orca's embedded browser (`orca-cli`).

Computer Use

Use this skill to drive a visible app window through orca computer. Prefer a programmatic path (shell, filesystem, git, HTTP, existing CLIs) whenever it can complete the task; use this skill only when a visible window needs GUI control those cannot reach. Do not use it for Orca's embedded browser (orca-cli).

Preconditions

  • ORCA is a placeholder for the executable you resolved in the stub; substitute it before running.
  • Prefer --json; see Screenshots below for image output.
  • Do not push, submit forms, send messages, buy items, delete data, change account settings, or expose secrets unless the user explicitly asked for that action.
  • If an app contains sensitive content, read only what the user requested.
ORCA computer capabilities --json

Core Loop

ORCA computer list-apps --json
ORCA computer get-app-state --app com.spotify.client --json
ORCA computer click --app com.spotify.client --element-index 42 --json

Use the fresh state returned by each action for the next element index. Element indexes are the numeric labels shown in the tree; they may be sparse when noisy sections are omitted, so never infer valid indexes from elementCount or "Visible elements." Element indexes are short-lived and go stale after delays, navigation, focus changes, scrolling, window changes, or app re-rendering.

In --json output, read the accessibility tree and action indexes from result.snapshot.treeText; elementCount is only a count and must not be used to infer indexes.

App Selectors

Prefer bundle IDs from list-apps; names are acceptable when unambiguous. Use pid:<number> only when bundle ID or name matching is ambiguous.

ORCA computer get-app-state --app com.microsoft.edgemac --json
ORCA computer get-app-state --app Spotify --json
ORCA computer get-app-state --app pid:12345 --json

For apps with multiple windows or ambiguous titles, run list-windows first. Prefer --window-id <id> when the listed id is not none; otherwise use --window-index <n>. Once you choose a window, pass the same selector to get-app-state and later actions until the target window changes.

Commands

ORCA computer permissions --json
ORCA computer capabilities --json
ORCA computer list-apps --json
ORCA computer list-windows --app <app> --json
ORCA computer get-app-state --app <app> --json
ORCA computer get-app-state --app <app> --restore-window --json
ORCA computer click --app <app> --element-index <index> --json
ORCA computer click --app <app> --x 100 --y 100 --json
ORCA computer click --app <app> --x 100 --y 100 --modifiers CmdOrCtrl+Shift --json
ORCA computer click --app <app> --element-index <index> --mouse-button right --json
ORCA computer click --app <app> --element-index <index> --mouse-button middle --json
ORCA computer perform-secondary-action --app <app> --element-index <index> --action <name> --json
ORCA computer set-value --app <app> --element-index <index> --value "text" --json
ORCA computer type-text --app <app> --text "text" --json
ORCA computer press-key --app <app> --key Return --json
ORCA computer hotkey --app <app> --key CmdOrCtrl+A --json
ORCA computer paste-text --app <app> --text "text" --json
ORCA computer scroll --app <app> (--element-index <index> | --x <x> --y <y>) --direction down --json
ORCA computer drag --app <app> --from-element-index <index> --to-element-index <index> --json
ORCA computer drag --app <app> --from-x 100 --from-y 100 --to-x 300 --to-y 300 --json

Use --no-screenshot only when pixels are not needed. Use --text-stdin or --value-stdin for sensitive text so payloads do not land in shell history. On Linux and Windows, action payloads still pass through a short-lived local operation file, so avoid sending secrets unless the user explicitly asked for them:

POSIX-shell example (use the equivalent stdin mechanism without command-history exposure in PowerShell or cmd.exe):

printf '%s' "$TEXT" | ORCA computer set-value --app <app> --element-index <index> --value-stdin --json

Action Rules

  • An action's verification is separate from whether its provider call succeeded:
    • verified means the changed value was read back.
    • unverified (accessibility action unasserted) means the accessibility call succeeded but no post-state assertion was made.
    • unverified (synthetic input) means input was fired into the void and is unverifiable.
    • Missing verification metadata is unverified, including responses from older runtimes.
    • Never report an unverified action as success. If it could have sent, submitted, bought, or deleted something, say the effect is unproven.
  • Prefer semantic actions: set-value for editable fields, click for controls, and perform-secondary-action only for listed action names.
  • After any UI-changing action, use the returned state or rerun get-app-state before choosing the next element index.
  • Use type-text only after focusing a field and confirming the app has a focused text receiver; synthetic keyboard delivery is reported as unverified, so inspect the returned state before assuming text landed.
  • Use press-key for single/navigation keys such as Return, Escape, Tab, and arrows. Use hotkey only for one modifier chord plus one key, such as CmdOrCtrl+A or CmdOrCtrl+Shift+P; prefer CmdOrCtrl+... for cross-platform combos.
  • Use click --modifiers <chord> for modifier-clicks. Never synthesize separate modifier-down and modifier-up commands around a click; interruption can leave a modifier logically held.
  • Some actions work in background apps, but this is app-dependent. If success does not change the UI, refresh state and choose a more semantic action or restore/focus the window.
  • Coordinates are window-local; use coordinates from the latest screenshot/state for the same target window.

Screenshots

get-app-state and actions request screenshots by default unless --no-screenshot is passed. A successful --json capture is normally saved at result.screenshot.path; if that path is absent, use the inline base64 result.screenshot.data. Pretty output does not save images.

Use the tree for indexes/actions and the screenshot for visual confirmation; failed capture usually means hidden, minimized, off-screen, or permission-blocked.

Coordinates passed to click, scroll, and drag are window-local action coordinates. If the screenshot reports scale other than 1, convert visual screenshot pixels before acting:

action_x = screenshot_pixel_x / screenshot.scale
action_y = screenshot_pixel_y / screenshot.scale

Prefer element indexes or element frames from the tree when available. Use raw screenshot-derived coordinates only after checking the latest screenshot scale and window size.

On Linux and Windows, screenshots may come from the visible desktop region for the target window bounds. If visual pixels matter, use --restore-window so another window does not cover the target region; if you cannot take focus, trust the tree over potentially occluded pixels.

App Notes

Browsers: for Edge, Chrome, Safari, and similar browser windows, set the address/search field directly, then press Return. Do not assume raw typing went to the address bar. Use --restore-window when the browser is not already frontmost. Large tab strips may show only the active tab plus an "inactive browser tabs omitted" marker; treat that as intentional noise reduction and operate on the current page/address bar unless the user asked to manage tabs.

For browser-hosted forms such as Gmail compose, verify the focused UI element after each field action. Page text fields can expose accessibility actions without moving DOM focus; if a click or set-value does not change the focused receiver, use Tab / Shift+Tab from a known focused field or window-local coordinates from a fresh screenshot. Prefer paste-text into the verified focused field for draft bodies, then inspect the returned state before continuing.

ORCA computer get-app-state --app com.microsoft.edgemac --restore-window --json
ORCA computer set-value --app com.microsoft.edgemac --element-index <addressBarIndex> --value "test123" --json
ORCA computer press-key --app com.microsoft.edgemac --key Return --json

Spotify: refresh after playback clicks; the UI often changes asynchronously.

Slack: the accessibility tree may be shallow while the screenshot contains useful information. Reading visible Slack UI is fine when requested; sending messages or triggering workflows still needs explicit permission.

Errors

  • app_not_found: run list-apps and retry with the bundle ID. If the target is a web app such as Gmail, choose the desktop browser app/window that contains it; do not retry ORCA computer ... --app Gmail unchanged because orca computer app selectors refer to desktop apps, not website names.
  • app_blocked: stop; the target is intentionally blocked from computer-use.
  • window_not_found / window_stale: run list-windows, choose a current selector, then rerun get-app-state.
  • window_not_focused: retry once with --restore-window; if the message says restore was already requested, stop retrying restore and bring the app forward manually or check permissions. For editable fields prefer set-value, then inspect before assuming keyboard input worked.
  • element_not_found: index is stale; run get-app-state again.
  • unsupported_capability: the provider or desktop environment cannot do that action; use a semantic alternative or install the missing dependency if the message names one.
  • action_not_supported: inspect the element's listed actions and retry with one of those names, or use click/set-value when appropriate.
  • value_not_settable: the element cannot accept direct value writes; focus it and use keyboard input only when the returned state can be inspected.
  • element_not_clickable: the element has no actionable frame; use a parent/child element with a frame or choose window-local coordinates from the latest screenshot.
  • invalid_argument: fix the command flags; do not retry the same command unchanged.
  • action_timeout: inspect current state before retrying, then use a simpler semantic action or --no-screenshot if observation is slow.
  • screenshot_failed: use --no-screenshot if tree state is enough; if the message names Screen Recording or screenshots permission, run ORCA computer permissions --id screenshots --json.
  • accessibility_error: run ORCA computer capabilities --json; if the message names Accessibility permission, run ORCA computer permissions --id accessibility --json.
  • Empty tree or no screenshot: app may have no visible window, be minimized, or need permissions.
  • Permission errors: run ORCA computer permissions --json, or ORCA computer permissions --id accessibility --json / --id screenshots --json when the message names one permission, use the setup UI, then retry.