mirror of
https://github.com/windmill-labs/windmill.git
synced 2026-08-18 16:02:10 +00:00
Ruben Fiszel
b13113964a
* fix(pipelines): canonicalize S3 asset keys so SDK writes and DuckDB reads connect
The SDK object forms — TS `writeS3File({s3:"exports/x"})` and Python
`write_s3_file(S3Object(s3="exports/x"))` — resolve to the URI `s3:///exports/x`
(empty default storage), whose parsed asset path was `/exports/x` (leading
slash). DuckDB `read_csv('s3://exports/x')` and the `// on s3://exports/x`
trigger form yielded the bare `exports/x`. The same object thus produced two
asset identities, so a DuckDB consumer never connected to a TS/Python producer
in the pipeline graph.
`parse_asset_syntax` (shared by the native backend parsers and the wasm parser
that drives `frontend/src/lib/infer.ts` and the CLI `localGraph`) now strips a
single leading slash from S3 paths, so `s3:///key`, `s3://storage/key`, DuckDB
`s3://…`, and `// on` all canonicalize to one key. Both deploy-time inference
and editor/CLI inference agree, and the producer's write edge and the
consumer's read/trigger edge share a node.
Only one leading slash is stripped, so `s3:///` triple-slash default-storage
keys collapse to the bare key while Hive-partition keys
(`s3://bucket/y=2024/f.parquet`) and explicit-storage `s3://storage/key` paths
are untouched. Non-S3 asset kinds (res://, ducklake://, …) keep their paths
verbatim.
Note: existing deployed pipelines that recorded `/key` paths need a redeploy to
pick up the canonical `key`; the fix is forward-consistent for anything parsed
after this change.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* docs(pipelines): mark S3 asset-path normalization (item 6) resolved
The open-issues list still flagged the SDK-form leading-slash vs bare-URI
no-slash mismatch as "Still open", contradicting the fix in this PR. Mark it
resolved to match the updated Language-coverage prose.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* docs+test(pipelines): disclose S3 explicit-storage vs default-storage-nested-key aliasing
Collapsing to one canonical key means `s3://storage/key` (explicit storage) and
`s3:///storage/key` (default-storage nested key) now alias to the same node
`storage/key`, though they name different objects. Low-probability (needs a
storage config named to match a default-storage prefix) and inherent to a
best-effort lineage graph that doesn't split the first segment as a storage
name, but previously undisclosed. Document the tradeoff and pin the intended
aliasing with a test so it's intentional, not a latent surprise.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* fix(pipelines): mirror S3 leading-slash strip in frontend live-preview parser
The pipeline graph live preview parses `// on` annotations client-side via the
hand-written `parsePipelineAnnotations.ts` (a TS mirror of the Rust annotation
scanner), NOT the wasm parser. Its `parseAssetSyntax` still returned the raw
suffix, so `// on s3:///exports/x` yielded `/exports/x` while the deploy-time
and wasm parsers now canonicalize to `exports/x`. `resolveGraph` synthesizes
trigger edges from that path, so the browser preview could still render
disconnected `/exports/x` and `exports/x` nodes for the exact triple-slash case
this PR fixes at deploy time.
Mirror the S3-only single-leading-slash strip in the TS parser and extend the
shared parity fixture corpus (run by both the Rust and TS parity suites) with
the triple-slash trigger case, so Rust/TS drift on this is now caught.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* fix(pipelines): seed slashless S3 template asset paths to match canonical key
`autoOutputAsset` seeded new S3 template outputs with a leading slash
(`/pipelines/…`), which the old parser required to match `s3:///key` writes.
This PR made `parse_asset_syntax` strip that slash, so the seeded draft asset
(stored as `outputAssets`, used by `resolveGraph` for inactive-draft node
identity) no longer matched the body-inferred identity `pipelines/…` — the live
preview could render a duplicate `/pipelines/…` node and a phantom post-deploy
drift warning.
Seed the canonical slashless key instead, and switch the DuckDB body's S3 URIs
from `s3://${path}` to `s3:///${path}` so the generated runtime URI stays the
triple-slash default-storage form byte-for-byte (the SDK sites already build
`s3:///` + bare key). Add a pure-logic parity test asserting, for every
language and S3 output kind, that the seeded asset path is slashless and that
every S3 URI the generated body emits is triple-slash and canonicalizes back to
that seeded path.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* fix(pipelines): canonicalize S3 keys in CLI + frontend bounded-cascade resolvers
Two more hand-written S3-URI sites returned the raw suffix, so `s3:///exports/x`
stayed `/exports/x` while native/wasm parsers now canonicalize to `exports/x`:
- `cli/src/commands/pipeline/localGraph.ts` — the no-wasm fallback `// on`
scanner (go/bash/ruby). A fallback consumer's `// on s3:///x` would not
connect to a wasm-inferred `x` producer in `wmill pipeline show/run --local`.
- `boundedCascade.ts` `assetUriToNodeId` (duplicated in the CLI and the frontend
AssetGraph engines, kept in sync) — `--to s3:///exports/x` / a cascade bound
token would not resolve against the canonical graph node `s3object:exports/x`.
`resolveToken` delegates here, so it is covered too.
Mirror the S3-only single-leading-slash strip in all three, and add `s3:///`
tests to the CLI local-graph fallback suite and both bounded-cascade suites
(explicit-storage and Hive-partition keys asserted untouched).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* docs(pipelines): phrase S3 template test comment as a current invariant
Describe the slashless-seed requirement as the invariant it is, not as change
history, per the AGENTS.md "describe the code as it is" rule.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* fix(pipelines): strip all leading slashes from S3 keys so trigger refs round-trip
`parse_asset_syntax` stripped only one leading slash, so `S3Object(s3="/x")` —
which resolves to the quad-slash URI `s3:////x` — parsed to path `/x`. But
`trigger_spec_to_row` rebuilds a stored trigger ref as `s3://<path>` =
`s3:///x`, which `parse_asset_trigger_ref` then parses back to `x`. The
producer recorded `/x` while its consumer trigger resolved to `x` → a broken
edge. The same asymmetry affects every `s3://`+path reconstruction site
(backend refs, frontend `assetUri`, page refs) whenever a path starts with `/`.
Strip ALL leading slashes so a canonical S3 path never starts with `/`; naive
`prefix + path` reconstruction then round-trips everywhere. Applied uniformly
across all six S3-URI sites (Rust `parse_asset_syntax`, the TS live-preview
parser, template `s3Key`, and the frontend+CLI `assetUriToNodeId` and CLI
fallback scanner). The pathological leading-slash key collapses to the bare key
— acceptable for a best-effort lineage graph that never split storage anyway.
Tests: a windmill-common round-trip test (parse → trigger_spec_to_row →
parse_asset_trigger_ref) over every URI form incl. the quad-slash case; a
`s3:////x` shared parity fixture (Rust + TS); and quad-slash assertions in the
Rust parser test and both bounded-cascade suites.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* test(pipelines): align S3 template parity helper with strip-all canonicalization
The template seed/body parity test's `canonicalS3Key` helper (and its comment)
still stripped a single leading slash, so it no longer mirrored the parser it
claims to pin. Strip all leading slashes to match `parse_asset_syntax` and the
frontend/CLI mirrors.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
---------
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>